image: rachel burgin florida alec

ALEC Exposed, for 24 Hours

What is the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC)?

For almost 40 years now, up to 300 of the largest US corporations—including Koch Industries, Verizon, Bank of America and Exxon—have used ALEC to push model legislation, which is beneficial to their corporate interests, into law in the states. ALEC boasts that a third of all state legislators in the US are members, introducing around 1,000 ALEC bills every year. By using ALEC to pursue their agenda, they are able to hide their fingerprints, avoid lobbying disclosure, and evade the kind of increased scrutiny that comes when citizens know it’s actually corporationsthat draftedsome of their most important laws. Recent ALEC bills have rolled back voting rights, reduced environmental protections and stripped away collective bargaining rights for workers around the country.

 

When Florida Rep. Rachel Burgin (R- 56) introduced a bill in November calling on the federal government to reduce taxes for corporations (HM 685), she made an embarrassing mistake. Rep. Burgin was introducing a bill she had received from the corporate-funded American Legislative Exchange Council.  A bill written by the Tax Foundation, corporate members of ALEC’s ‘Tax and Fiscal Policy task force” and a group founded and funded by major corporate interests, including the billionaire Koch brothers.

image: bergin alec bill

All ALEC model resolutions contain a boilerplate paragraph, describing ALEC’s adherence to free market principles and limited government.  When legislators introduce one of ALEC’s bills, they normally remove this paragraph. Sometimes (but only sometimes) legislators will make some slight alterations to anALEC model bill,perhaps to include something specific to them or to their state. Rep. Burgin didn’t do that.  Instead she introduced a bill that was the same as the model word-for-word, forgetting even to remove the paragraph naming ALEC and describing its principles.

As a Texas Governor might say; “Oops!”

The next day, Rep. Burgin quickly withdrew the bill hoping that no one had noticed and then re-introduced it 24-hours later, with a new bill number (HM 717), but now without the problematic paragraph. Nobody seems to have noticed until now.

With some justification, you might ask why this really matters: even if this bill passed it wouldn’t force Congress to act. However, I think it matters because the states play a very significant role in setting the national agenda. Corporations know this, which is why they frequently use ALEC to secretly introduce their model bills, creating the impression of widespread popular uproar in the state houses. In recent years they have used this mechanism for both attacks on the EPA’s regulation of greenhouse gases (ALEC bill introduced in 22 states) and in pushing back against the Affordable Care Act (ALEC bill introduced in 44 states).

It also matters because the question of whether corporations should pay more or less in tax is an issue that gets to the heart of politics in America. Common Cause board chair Robert Reich writes about this tension between corporate influence and America’s economic trajectory in an op-ed published in today’s Chicago Tribune.

Rep. Burgin’s (revised) bill to reduce corporate taxes has already been voted out of the Federal Affairs Subcommittee, and is due to have a hearing in the State Affairs Committee soon. Only one external voice was heard at the subcommittee hearing, a lobbyist from the Associated Industries of Florida (AIF), a lobby group who themselves have links to ALEC. AIF is now run by notorious ex-Congressman and Florida Speaker Tom Feeney, who not only was caught up in the Jack Abramoff scandal, but was once named one of the “20 Most Corrupt Members of Congress” by the organization Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington.

It matters who writes our laws and it matters who stands to benefit from them.  When these are the very same entity, then we as citizens should have the right to know this.

 

»Follow Common Cause’s ongoing work on ALEC and to learn more about corporations writing legislation.

 

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Twitter Digg Delicious Stumbleupon Technorati Facebook Email

About Nick Surgey

Nick Surgey is staff counsel at Common Cause. Follow him on Twitter @NickSurgeyCC.

139 Responses to “ALEC Exposed, for 24 Hours”

  1. Thanks to Common Cause, we need to get this message out! Unfortunatly, most people never heard of Alec!!

  2. Thanks to Common Cause, we need to get this message out! Unfortunatly, most people never heard of Alec!!

  3. Thanks to Common Cause, we need to get this message out! Unfortunatly, most people never heard of Alec!!

  4. This is exactly what Romney says we shouldn’t be talking about except in “quiet rooms.” Every American voter has a responsibility to understand who is attempting to buy this government and to insure with the vote that it does not succeed.

  5. This is exactly what Romney says we shouldn’t be talking about except in “quiet rooms.” Every American voter has a responsibility to understand who is attempting to buy this government and to insure with the vote that it does not succeed.

  6. This is exactly what Romney says we shouldn’t be talking about except in “quiet rooms.” Every American voter has a responsibility to understand who is attempting to buy this government and to insure with the vote that it does not succeed.

  7. Sounds like collusion to me. Should be illegal.

  8. Sounds like collusion to me. Should be illegal.

  9. Sounds like collusion to me. Should be illegal.

  10. So laziness and corruption are partners? I guess that shouldn’t surprise me.

  11. So laziness and corruption are partners? I guess that shouldn’t surprise me.

  12. So laziness and corruption are partners? I guess that shouldn’t surprise me.

  13. bad girl – no envelope for you

  14. bad girl – no envelope for you

  15. bad girl – no envelope for you

  16. Just learned that Rep. Rachel Burgin (R- 56) has a BS from Moody Bible College. Should we take that as being significant?

  17. Just learned that Rep. Rachel Burgin (R- 56) has a BS from Moody Bible College. Should we take that as being significant?

  18. Just learned that Rep. Rachel Burgin (R- 56) has a BS from Moody Bible College. Should we take that as being significant?

  19. You should have kept this quiet and accumulated more before reporting it. Love it.

  20. You should have kept this quiet and accumulated more before reporting it. Love it.

  21. You should have kept this quiet and accumulated more before reporting it. Love it.

  22. This is so infuriating. I wish it would go viral. So all of our country knew. This is deplorable. We M U S T take our democracy back ASAP

  23. This is so infuriating. I wish it would go viral. So all of our country knew. This is deplorable. We M U S T take our democracy back ASAP

  24. This is so infuriating. I wish it would go viral. So all of our country knew. This is deplorable. We M U S T take our democracy back ASAP

  25. Oh Tom Feeney is even more…. He was the Florida Speaker of the house during the 2000 election debacle, announcing FL would defy the Supreme Court in awarding the state’s electors (and more). He was Jeb Bush’s running mate, Tom Delay’s BFF in Congress. Dude is a right wing embed career operative, like Karen Handel’s recent work with the rightward lurch of the Komen Foundation.

  26. Oh Tom Feeney is even more…. He was the Florida Speaker of the house during the 2000 election debacle, announcing FL would defy the Supreme Court in awarding the state’s electors (and more). He was Jeb Bush’s running mate, Tom Delay’s BFF in Congress. Dude is a right wing embed career operative, like Karen Handel’s recent work with the rightward lurch of the Komen Foundation.

  27. Oh Tom Feeney is even more…. He was the Florida Speaker of the house during the 2000 election debacle, announcing FL would defy the Supreme Court in awarding the state’s electors (and more). He was Jeb Bush’s running mate, Tom Delay’s BFF in Congress. Dude is a right wing embed career operative, like Karen Handel’s recent work with the rightward lurch of the Komen Foundation.

  28. Democrats take money to. Lets not make this one side issue.

    • Nikki Willoughby May 9, 2012 at 9:52 pm

      You’re right, and this isn’t a partisan issue. It’s an issue of transparency and whether elected officials (no matter their party affiliation) are working in the public interest.

  29. Democrats take money to. Lets not make this one side issue.

    • Nikki Willoughby May 9, 2012 at 9:52 pm

      You’re right, and this isn’t a partisan issue. It’s an issue of transparency and whether elected officials (no matter their party affiliation) are working in the public interest.

  30. Democrats take money to. Lets not make this one side issue.

    • Nikki Willoughby May 9, 2012 at 9:52 pm

      You’re right, and this isn’t a partisan issue. It’s an issue of transparency and whether elected officials (no matter their party affiliation) are working in the public interest.

  31. Wohh just what I was looking for, thanks for posting.

  32. Wohh just what I was looking for, thanks for posting.

  33. Wohh just what I was looking for, thanks for posting.

  34. I haven’t checked in here for some time since I thought it was getting boring, but the last few posts are good quality so I guess I will add you back to my daily bloglist. You deserve it my friend :)

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. » Florida Republican Submits Anti-Corporate Tax Bill Without Removing ALEC Mission Statement - February 1, 2012

    [...] has made the task of indicting ALEC for undue influence in state politics that much easier by forgetting to remove ALEC’s mission statement from a bill (PDF) she suddenly “decided” to propose. This bill calls on the federal [...]

  2. » Florida Republican Submits Anti-Corporate Tax Bill Without Removing ALEC Mission Statement - February 1, 2012

    [...] has made the task of indicting ALEC for undue influence in state politics that much easier by forgetting to remove ALEC’s mission statement from a bill (PDF) she suddenly “decided” to propose. This bill calls on the federal [...]

  3. » Florida Republican Submits Anti-Corporate Tax Bill Without Removing ALEC Mission Statement - February 1, 2012

    [...] has made the task of indicting ALEC for undue influence in state politics that much easier by forgetting to remove ALEC’s mission statement from a bill (PDF) she suddenly “decided” to propose. This bill calls on the federal [...]

  4. WeMustChange » Blog Archive » Oops: Florida Republican Forgets To Remove ALEC Mission Statement From Boilerplate Anti-Tax Bill - February 2, 2012

    [...] that would officially call on the federal government to reduce corporate taxes, but she apparently forgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from the top of the bill, which she seems to have copied word-for-word [...]

  5. WeMustChange » Blog Archive » Oops: Florida Republican Forgets To Remove ALEC Mission Statement From Boilerplate Anti-Tax Bill - February 2, 2012

    [...] that would officially call on the federal government to reduce corporate taxes, but she apparently forgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from the top of the bill, which she seems to have copied word-for-word [...]

  6. WeMustChange » Blog Archive » Oops: Florida Republican Forgets To Remove ALEC Mission Statement From Boilerplate Anti-Tax Bill - February 2, 2012

    [...] that would officially call on the federal government to reduce corporate taxes, but she apparently forgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from the top of the bill, which she seems to have copied word-for-word [...]

  7. Clocking Out: I Can Haz Democracy? Edition « Main Street - February 2, 2012

    [...] Whoops. Florida state legislator forgets to take ALEC mission statement out of an ALEC-authored bill she submitted. [...]

  8. Clocking Out: I Can Haz Democracy? Edition « Main Street - February 2, 2012

    [...] Whoops. Florida state legislator forgets to take ALEC mission statement out of an ALEC-authored bill she submitted. [...]

  9. Clocking Out: I Can Haz Democracy? Edition « Main Street - February 2, 2012

    [...] Whoops. Florida state legislator forgets to take ALEC mission statement out of an ALEC-authored bill she submitted. [...]

  10. {2012 ELECTIONS} — Alec exposed in Florida….for 24 hours | getcentered - February 2, 2012

    [...] To many exploring what exactly is wrong with our government and why is it broken, much of the blame is placed at the feet of the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC). Here is a brief description of the dangers of ALEC from Common Blog, [...]

  11. {2012 ELECTIONS} — Alec exposed in Florida….for 24 hours | getcentered - February 2, 2012

    [...] To many exploring what exactly is wrong with our government and why is it broken, much of the blame is placed at the feet of the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC). Here is a brief description of the dangers of ALEC from Common Blog, [...]

  12. {2012 ELECTIONS} — Alec exposed in Florida….for 24 hours | getcentered - February 2, 2012

    [...] To many exploring what exactly is wrong with our government and why is it broken, much of the blame is placed at the feet of the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC). Here is a brief description of the dangers of ALEC from Common Blog, [...]

  13. Oops: Florida Republican Forgets To Remove ALEC Mission Statement From Boilerplate Anti-Tax Bill « The Fifth Column - February 3, 2012

    [...] that would officially call on the federal government to reduce corporate taxes, but she apparentlyforgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from the top of the bill, which she seems to have copied word-for-word [...]

  14. Oops: Florida Republican Forgets To Remove ALEC Mission Statement From Boilerplate Anti-Tax Bill « The Fifth Column - February 3, 2012

    [...] that would officially call on the federal government to reduce corporate taxes, but she apparentlyforgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from the top of the bill, which she seems to have copied word-for-word [...]

  15. Oops: Florida Republican Forgets To Remove ALEC Mission Statement From Boilerplate Anti-Tax Bill « The Fifth Column - February 3, 2012

    [...] that would officially call on the federal government to reduce corporate taxes, but she apparentlyforgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from the top of the bill, which she seems to have copied word-for-word [...]

  16. Getting Past Guns, God And Gays Legislation - February 4, 2012

    [...] One bill I really like is the Influence Disclosure Bill introduced by House Minority Leader Craig Fitzhugh. This bill (HB 2031) would require all model bills filed to be identified from the source. An example would be bills which come from organizations like ALEC. An example of why Fitzhugh’s bill is important is here where a Florida legislator got caught introducing legislation that had ALEC literally written all over it. [...]

  17. Getting Past Guns, God And Gays Legislation - February 4, 2012

    [...] One bill I really like is the Influence Disclosure Bill introduced by House Minority Leader Craig Fitzhugh. This bill (HB 2031) would require all model bills filed to be identified from the source. An example would be bills which come from organizations like ALEC. An example of why Fitzhugh’s bill is important is here where a Florida legislator got caught introducing legislation that had ALEC literally written all over it. [...]

  18. Getting Past Guns, God And Gays Legislation - February 4, 2012

    [...] One bill I really like is the Influence Disclosure Bill introduced by House Minority Leader Craig Fitzhugh. This bill (HB 2031) would require all model bills filed to be identified from the source. An example would be bills which come from organizations like ALEC. An example of why Fitzhugh’s bill is important is here where a Florida legislator got caught introducing legislation that had ALEC literally written all over it. [...]

  19. How Deep is ALEC’s Reach into Driving Florida Legislation? | Scathing Purple Musings - February 4, 2012

    [...] But its clear that some republican legislators are still submitting ALEC written bills. In November, Rep. Rachel Burgin of Riverview had to quickly withdraw a bill which still had ALEC’s introductory clause in it. ALEC is also involved in advancing the [...]

  20. How Deep is ALEC’s Reach into Driving Florida Legislation? | Scathing Purple Musings - February 4, 2012

    [...] But its clear that some republican legislators are still submitting ALEC written bills. In November, Rep. Rachel Burgin of Riverview had to quickly withdraw a bill which still had ALEC’s introductory clause in it. ALEC is also involved in advancing the [...]

  21. How Deep is ALEC’s Reach into Driving Florida Legislation? | Scathing Purple Musings - February 4, 2012

    [...] But its clear that some republican legislators are still submitting ALEC written bills. In November, Rep. Rachel Burgin of Riverview had to quickly withdraw a bill which still had ALEC’s introductory clause in it. ALEC is also involved in advancing the [...]

  22. Scary Guys Named Saul and other short notes « The Weekly Sift - February 6, 2012

    [...] Who really writes your laws? When a Florida representative proposed a bill written by the corporate-sponsored American Legislative Exchange Council, she forgot to remove the ALEC mission statement. [...]

  23. Scary Guys Named Saul and other short notes « The Weekly Sift - February 6, 2012

    [...] Who really writes your laws? When a Florida representative proposed a bill written by the corporate-sponsored American Legislative Exchange Council, she forgot to remove the ALEC mission statement. [...]

  24. Scary Guys Named Saul and other short notes « The Weekly Sift - February 6, 2012

    [...] Who really writes your laws? When a Florida representative proposed a bill written by the corporate-sponsored American Legislative Exchange Council, she forgot to remove the ALEC mission statement. [...]

  25. NewsLinks | Intrepid Report.com - February 7, 2012

    [...] that would officially call on the federal government to reduce corporate taxes, but she apparently forgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from the top of the bill, which she seems to have copied word-for-word [...]

  26. NewsLinks | Intrepid Report.com - February 7, 2012

    [...] that would officially call on the federal government to reduce corporate taxes, but she apparently forgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from the top of the bill, which she seems to have copied word-for-word [...]

  27. NewsLinks | Intrepid Report.com - February 7, 2012

    [...] that would officially call on the federal government to reduce corporate taxes, but she apparently forgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from the top of the bill, which she seems to have copied word-for-word [...]

  28. Many many linky « Dissent of a Woman - February 7, 2012

    [...] Dipshit FL state legislator shows off her ALEC puppet strings.   [...]

  29. Many many linky « Dissent of a Woman - February 7, 2012

    [...] Dipshit FL state legislator shows off her ALEC puppet strings.   [...]

  30. Many many linky « Dissent of a Woman - February 7, 2012

    [...] Dipshit FL state legislator shows off her ALEC puppet strings.   [...]

  31. Not a Smart ALEC: Stupid and Evil | Mike the Mad Biologist - February 7, 2012

    [...] that would officially call on the federal government to reduce corporate taxes, but she apparently forgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from the top of the bill, which she seems to have copied word-for-word [...]

  32. Not a Smart ALEC: Stupid and Evil | Mike the Mad Biologist - February 7, 2012

    [...] that would officially call on the federal government to reduce corporate taxes, but she apparently forgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from the top of the bill, which she seems to have copied word-for-word [...]

  33. Not a Smart ALEC: Stupid and Evil | Mike the Mad Biologist - February 7, 2012

    [...] that would officially call on the federal government to reduce corporate taxes, but she apparently forgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from the top of the bill, which she seems to have copied word-for-word [...]

  34. Far-right corporados are not your friends « Occupy The Airwaves - February 8, 2012

    [...] Luckily for us, what appears to be Burgin’s slip of the tongue offers some insight as to how ALEC works with its members. (Burgin did not immediately respond to my requests for comment.) CommonBlog, the Common Cause blog that first noticed Burgin’s bill, reports: [...]

  35. Far-right corporados are not your friends « Occupy The Airwaves - February 8, 2012

    [...] Luckily for us, what appears to be Burgin’s slip of the tongue offers some insight as to how ALEC works with its members. (Burgin did not immediately respond to my requests for comment.) CommonBlog, the Common Cause blog that first noticed Burgin’s bill, reports: [...]

  36. Far-right corporados are not your friends « Occupy The Airwaves - February 8, 2012

    [...] Luckily for us, what appears to be Burgin’s slip of the tongue offers some insight as to how ALEC works with its members. (Burgin did not immediately respond to my requests for comment.) CommonBlog, the Common Cause blog that first noticed Burgin’s bill, reports: [...]

  37. UW #education dean and faculty member highlight the treat of #ALEC on #publicschools « At the Chalk Face - February 21, 2012

    [...] There was a story recently about how an esteemed Florida legislator forgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from a model bill. Oops. Share this:Like this:LikeBe the first to like this post. [...]

  38. UW #education dean and faculty member highlight the treat of #ALEC on #publicschools « At the Chalk Face - February 21, 2012

    [...] There was a story recently about how an esteemed Florida legislator forgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from a model bill. Oops. Share this:Like this:LikeBe the first to like this post. [...]

  39. UW #education dean and faculty member highlight the treat of #ALEC on #publicschools « At the Chalk Face - February 21, 2012

    [...] There was a story recently about how an esteemed Florida legislator forgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from a model bill. Oops. Share this:Like this:LikeBe the first to like this post. [...]

  40. JOIN OCCUPY NAPLES IN ORGANIZING TO OUST AMERICAN LEGISLATIVE EXCHANGE COUNCIL (ALEC) POLITICIANS IN FLORIDA | OCCUPY NAPLES - February 21, 2012

    [...] LINKS:Common Cause broke the Burgin story http://www.commonblog.com/2012/01/31/alec-exposed-for-24-hours/                             The Center for Media and Democracy hosts a [...]

  41. JOIN OCCUPY NAPLES IN ORGANIZING TO OUST AMERICAN LEGISLATIVE EXCHANGE COUNCIL (ALEC) POLITICIANS IN FLORIDA | OCCUPY NAPLES - February 21, 2012

    [...] LINKS:Common Cause broke the Burgin story http://www.commonblog.com/2012/01/31/alec-exposed-for-24-hours/                             The Center for Media and Democracy hosts a [...]

  42. JOIN OCCUPY NAPLES IN ORGANIZING TO OUST AMERICAN LEGISLATIVE EXCHANGE COUNCIL (ALEC) POLITICIANS IN FLORIDA | OCCUPY NAPLES - February 21, 2012

    [...] LINKS:Common Cause broke the Burgin story http://www.commonblog.com/2012/01/31/alec-exposed-for-24-hours/                             The Center for Media and Democracy hosts a [...]

  43. It Ain’t Just Bidness « ENDAblog - February 29, 2012

    [...] that would officially call on the federal government to reduce corporate taxes, but she apparently forgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from the top of the bill, which she seems to have copied word-for-word [...]

  44. It Ain’t Just Bidness « ENDAblog - February 29, 2012

    [...] that would officially call on the federal government to reduce corporate taxes, but she apparently forgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from the top of the bill, which she seems to have copied word-for-word [...]

  45. It Ain’t Just Bidness « ENDAblog - February 29, 2012

    [...] that would officially call on the federal government to reduce corporate taxes, but she apparently forgot to remove ALEC’s mission statement from the top of the bill, which she seems to have copied word-for-word [...]

  46. First Paragraph Of Florida GOP Legislator’s Bill: ALEC’s Mission Statement « Mercury Rising 鳯女 - March 17, 2012

    [...] Seriously, they’re actually doing this: When Florida Rep. Rachel Burgin (R- 56) introduced a bill in November calling on the federal government to reduce taxes for corporations (HM 685), she made an embarrassing mistake. Rep. Burgin was introducing a bill she had received from the corporate-funded American Legislative Exchange Council.  A bill written by the Tax Foundation, corporate members of ALEC’s ‘Tax and Fiscal Policy task force” and a group founded and funded by major corporate interests, including the billionaire Koch brothers. [...]

  47. First Paragraph Of Florida GOP Legislator’s Bill: ALEC’s Mission Statement « Mercury Rising 鳯女 - March 17, 2012

    [...] Seriously, they’re actually doing this: When Florida Rep. Rachel Burgin (R- 56) introduced a bill in November calling on the federal government to reduce taxes for corporations (HM 685), she made an embarrassing mistake. Rep. Burgin was introducing a bill she had received from the corporate-funded American Legislative Exchange Council.  A bill written by the Tax Foundation, corporate members of ALEC’s ‘Tax and Fiscal Policy task force” and a group founded and funded by major corporate interests, including the billionaire Koch brothers. [...]

  48. First Paragraph Of Florida GOP Legislator’s Bill: ALEC’s Mission Statement « Mercury Rising 鳯女 - March 17, 2012

    [...] Seriously, they’re actually doing this: When Florida Rep. Rachel Burgin (R- 56) introduced a bill in November calling on the federal government to reduce taxes for corporations (HM 685), she made an embarrassing mistake. Rep. Burgin was introducing a bill she had received from the corporate-funded American Legislative Exchange Council.  A bill written by the Tax Foundation, corporate members of ALEC’s ‘Tax and Fiscal Policy task force” and a group founded and funded by major corporate interests, including the billionaire Koch brothers. [...]

  49. Exposing ALEC: How Conservative-Backed State Laws Are All Connected « Florida News Now - April 14, 2012

    [...] Burgin yanked the bill back a day later, but it was too late. Common Cause researcher Nick Surgey posted about it on the organization’s blog. It got picked up in social media and joked about on cable [...]

  50. Exposing ALEC: How Conservative-Backed State Laws Are All Connected « Florida News Now - April 14, 2012

    [...] Burgin yanked the bill back a day later, but it was too late. Common Cause researcher Nick Surgey posted about it on the organization’s blog. It got picked up in social media and joked about on cable [...]