Common Cause - Holding Power ResponsibleCommon Cause - Holding Power Responsible

Topics
Our Issues
Money in Politics
Election Reform
Media and Democracy
Ethics in Government
Government Accountability
Press Center
Research Center
Register to Vote

Sign Up and join the Community - click here

An Important Victory: Blackwell Loses in Court

You may remember that attorney Cliff Arnebeck, a board member of Common Cause Ohio, was threatened with sanctions for his activism concerning the recount effort and other suits related to the November 2nd, 2004, election in Ohio.

We believe that such an action (sanctioning activists for questioning the outcome of an election) would have a chilling effect on others' efforts to raise reasonable doubts about election administration and election validity -- and indeed we believe that was the intent behind the motions for sanctions, which were entered by Attorney General Petro at the official request of Secretary of State Kenneth Blackwell.

Therefore, we're glad to know that Blackwell's effort failed. In an email today, Cliff sent us the good news that, "Decisions [were] issued today denying the motions for sanctions in the elections contests we filed."

Sometimes the good guys win, even in Ohio!


Tags: (all tags)


Display:

Thanks for posting this Barb

Sounds like the court in Ohio did not want any thing to do with Sec. Blackwell's blaming the messanger approach.

.Also, the decision has been posted on Ohio Honest Elections Campaign website.

by Murshed Zaheed on Thu May 19, 2005 at 03:01:31 PM EST


Here's the AP article

By THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

Published: May 19, 2005

Filed at 11:41 a.m. ET

COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) -- Ending one of the last fights from the contentious 2004 presidential campaign, the Ohio Supreme Court on Thursday declined to punish four attorneys who had challenged the results in court.

Chief Justice Thomas Moyer ruled against Ohio Attorney General Jim Petro's attempt to have the lawyers sanctioned for filing ''a meritless claim'' against the vote that gave President Bush a win in Ohio and, as a result, enough electoral votes to win a second term in the White House.

In legal documents filed with the state Supreme Court, the lawyers had said the challenge they filed on behalf of 37 voters included enough evidence of voting irregularities to back up their allegations of widespread fraud. They later withdrew the claim.

Petro, a Republican, asked for sanctions against lawyers Cliff Arnebeck, Robert Fitrakis, Susan Truitt and Peter Peckarsky. If the court had sanctioned the lawyers, they could have been forced to repay attorney's fees and court costs.

Moyer, acting under the court's power to assign election-related complaints to a single justice, said that while the court has the authority to sanction attorneys, the speed with which elections must be challenged allows the court some leeway.

''The General Assembly could have expressly authorized courts to sanction those who pursue frivolous election contests. It has not,'' Moyer, a Republican, wrote in his decision.

President Bush beat Democratic Sen. John Kerry by about 118,000 votes in Ohio, which turned out to be the pivotal state in the Nov. 2 election. The lawyers' election challenge was withdrawn in early January, with those contesting the results saying it was clear their argument would be dismissed as moot with Bush set to be inaugurated.

Barbara Burt, Common Cause Election Reform Team Leader

by Barb Burt on Thu May 19, 2005 at 04:35:49 PM EST


Rally and Election Reform Teach-In Soon

Thanks, Barb,  for the posting of latest Ohio news.  Here's an event you should know about...

http://www.ohiovigilance.org/

by David K on Thu May 19, 2005 at 05:29:42 PM EST


RE: Compatibility Concern

xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer xoomer

by deaz on Sat Sep 09, 2006 at 09:13:02 AM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account just by filling out the form below. It's quick and free.


contact us | volunteer/intern programs | employment opportunities | site map | privacy policy