News War
By Celia Wexler
Posted on Tue Feb 13, 2007 at 09:37:43 AM EST
I belong to the Committee of Concerned Journalists, and last night attended a preview of
"News War: Secrets, Spin and the Future of News" that
Frontline will begin airing
on PBS at 9 p.m. tonight. I can't tell you much about the series, because
Frontline opted to show us a very small slice of the series, which will be aired in four segments this month and next. What I can tell you is that the panel discussion to promote the series reminded me once again, of why I left mainstream journalism. The panelists seemed totally oblivious to the huge fight to totally corporatize our media, including the Internet, and its implication for diversity of viewpoint, freedom of expression, and innovation.
Indeed, when I asked a question about net neutrality -- the right of individuals to access any information and use any lawful application on the Internet without the interference of an Internet Service Provider -- the panelists were almost totally unresponsive. Dana Priest, a very big-time Washington Post reporter, asked: "What's net neutrality?" The fact that she asked the question truly is an indictment of her own newspaper, which continues to cover media issues as business stories, and buries them in the business section of their paper.
But far more disappointing was the response of Scott Moore, vice president for Yahoo! News, who explained net neutrality to his colleagues on the panel, but then claimed it was "a tempest in a teapot," offering the bogus argument that in a competitive media marketplace, any company that withheld content that people wanted would find those individuals choosing another cable or broadband provider. Of course, that argument is so fraught with inaccuracies, it is pathetic. First of all, everyone knows that when a consumer contracts with a cable or telephone company for a bundle of services, it is extremely difficult to switch services. Secondly, companies are not going to cut off access to information, they are just going to make some information way more difficult to get to. You won't be able to find www.commoncause.org on a search engine, or when you try to access us, it will take far longer to reach us.
It is no secret that cable and phone companies want to make the Internet a vehicle for selling things and entertainment, a replica of cable with all its lack of choice and big profits.
The other very discouraging aspect of the panel was Leonard Downie's views on
The Washington Post and its stellar journalism. Downie is executive editor at
The Post, and he symbolizes all the arrogance of mainstream journalists who truly believe they never make mistakes and serve their communities well.
The Post is a very good newspaper, but I cringed when Downie's idea of increasing local coverage was using the Internet version of
The Post to transmit more news about local high school games in Loudon County! Or to give a forum for local sermons!
The Post as Internet Penneysaver! The Internet could permit
The Post to amp up its coverage of inner city Washington, of homelessness, of Prince George's County and its middle class. Or how about a video "day in the life" of a typical DC student in one of the city's crumbling school buildings?
So my advice to my readers is this:
E-mail Scott Moore and tell him that Net Neutrality is not a tempest in a teapot. I am guessing, but I think this is his e-mail: smoore@yahoo-inc.com. If that doesn't get you anywhere, you can complain about his comments to bnelson@yahoo-inc.com. He is one of their media contact people.
E-mail the Washington Post ombudsman Deborah Howell and ask her why The Post fails to cover media issues as political stories of major importance, rather than shuttle them all to the business section? Educate her about net neutrality and ask for more coverage in the A section of the newspaper: ombudsman@washpost.com.
The only really useful comment that came out of this pedestrian panel was from Dave Marash, a longtime journalist now a correspondent for Al Jazeera International. Lamenting the difficulty of journalists to report serious, substantive stories, he observed that when people lack the information they need, it has consequences. "Ignorance bites you in the ass," he said.
Tags: Frontline, journalism, Yahoo, Washington Post, net neutrality (all tags)
You are not logged in.
In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.
If not, you can make an account just by filling out the form below. It's quick and free.