Like a Knife Through Butter
By Lauren Coletta
Posted on Thu Jul 03, 2008 at 02:42:07 PM EST
We've been watching closely as a concurrent resolution on American policy on Iran moves its way swiftly through the House and Senate (hcon.res.362 and sres580). You can read the full bill and check out if your member is a cosponsor here. Some parts of the resolution are harmless, some are pandering, all of it political in an election year, but section 3 in the House version is down right dumb. It reads:
(3) demands that the President initiate an international effort to immediately and dramatically increase the economic, political, and diplomatic pressure on Iran to verifiably suspend its nuclear enrichment activities by, inter alia, prohibiting the export to Iran of all refined petroleum products; imposing stringent inspection requirements on all persons, vehicles, ships, planes, trains, and cargo entering or departing Iran; and prohibiting the international movement of all Iranian officials not involved in negotiating the suspension of Iran's nuclear program
We thought it sounded a lot like a military blockade, and that sounded a lot like an act of war. We checked with some former high ranking military and security experts and they felt the idea was absurd for a number of reasons.
1. The US could not unilaterally undertake a military blockade of Iran unless the international community agreed, an event not likely given the nations depending on Iranian oil supplies. If it chose to act unilaterally it would mean imposing stringent inspections on all the cargo ships of other nations as well..an act they wouldn't likely look at too fondly.
2. Given the strategic nature of the Gulf it would turn the oil markets upside down at a time when markets are as touchy as ever.
3. It gives the President overly broad powers beyond what the Constitution allows when declaring war..and that's what a blockade is.
4. The timing couldn't be worse as the current negotiations with Iran are showing some positive signs with their statement this week that they would be willing to put a freeze on their enrichment program.
Sponsors in the House and Senate contend that the language doesn't equal blockade but many in a position to know disagree. We will be putting a letter together after the July 4th break from qualified folks to make this point and hopefully quelched this resolution or at least the worst parts of it. In the mean time visit www.thomas.gov and see if your Member is cosponsor (there are all ready 220 of them) and tell them that now is not the time to make poorly conceived proclamations about military action against Iran.
Tags: International, Iran, Foreign Affairs (all tags)
You are not logged in.
In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.
If not, you can make an account just by filling out the form below. It's quick and free.