Following is a report from Common Cause Intern Tristan Schulhof:
John Shattuck, a member of Common Cause's National Governing Board and CEO of JFK Library Foundation, recently wrote an Op-Ed in The Boston Globe concerning the creation of a U.S. Human Rights Commission. He discusses America's poor human rights record and the damage it has created to our global prestige. But, Shattuck also suggests ways in which our credibility can be restored. Firstly, "the United States was founded on the rule of law" and therefore we must abide by it. Secondly, we must practice what we preach and not criticize others for human rights abuses. After we have done the above, we must create a truth commission in order to "...get the truth about recent abuses of human rights and the rule of law by the U.S. government." Lastly, Shattuck believes that there should be a U.S. Human Rights commission that would use its oversight and authority to require the executive "...to provide regular reports to the commission on how it is complying with international human rights treaties..."
Similarly, Common Cause (CC) and the Partnership for a Secure America (PSA) are gathering resources to conduct a national campaign to educate the public and policy makers about the importance of convening a bipartisan high level Human Rights Commission. The creation of such a commission is a concrete way to demonstrate that the U.S. rejects recent violations in this area and is committed to ensuring such actions are not repeated. The grassroots strength and outreach capabilities of CC and PSA will be effective in promoting the issue and educating the public.
In the post 9/11 world of global terrorism and the Iraq War, America's poor human rights record has discredited our government. As General Wesley K. Clark so effectively put it, "For shame, America, that we aren't brave enough and strong enough to live our values." Let's put an end to Guantanamo Bay and other incidents of torture and restore the respect for civil liberties that America once symbolized.
Common Cause has launched a campaign, Recapture the Flag, to demand a President and Congress that believe in the Constitution, the rule of law and justice for all. Seems obvious that any elected official should fervently support the rule of law. But, as Bruce Springsteen said on
60 Minutes, that's not the way it's been:
"I think we've seen things happen over the past six years that I don't think anybody ever thought they'd ever see in the United States," Springsteen says. "When people think of the United States' identity, they don't think of torture. They don't think of illegal wiretapping. They don't think of voter suppression," he says. "They don't think of no habeas corpus," he says, a reference to prisoners at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. ... "Those are things that are anti-American," Springsteen adds. "There's been a whole series of things that ... I never thought I'd ever see in America."
What do we do about that?
"It's unpatriotic at any given moment to sit back and let things pass that are damaging to some place that you love so dearly and that has given me so much."
Agree with Bruce? Then join our campaign at
recapturetheflag.com
Today there was a House Judiciary subcommittee meeting which has been described by Keith Perine of CQ as "political theater." Douglas J. Feith, former Undersecretary of Defense for Policy, was defending his role in developing the interrogation policies used on detainees by the current administration.
Many critics of the current administration have asserted that the "harsh" interrogation practices are equivalent to torture. This Thursday, there is to be a hearing held by the House Judiciary Constitution, Civil Rights, and Civil Liberties subcommittee to further investigate the legality of the current (and former) techniques.
There has been effort to disrupt the hearing and prevent new information from coming to light, and it has been said that Attorney General Michael B. Mukasey refused a request to appoint a special counsel to investigate the roles of administration lawyers and policy makers.
Last week, Common Cause launched its Recapture the Flag campaign urging congressional and presidential candidates to sign a pledge to:
*End torture, respect human rights and restore America's reputation in the world.
*Respect the rule of law and fiercely challenge anyone who seeks to undermine the Constitution and the Bill of Rights.
*Root out corruption, special interest abuses and partisan prejudice in the administration of justice.
*Hold to account - without exception - anyone who breaks the law or violates the public trust
Failing to investigate the legality of interrogation techniques is an abuse of power. Our system of democracy is based upon the ability to question in order to maintain a healthy balance of power.
Cross-posted on The Hill Blog. Sen. Ted Kennedy (D-Mass.) said it best today as the Senate Judiciary Committee voted to approve the nomination of Judge Michael Mukasey as attorney general
"He will, in fact, enforce the laws that we pass in the future?" Kennedy said, mocking the assurances Mukasey gave to Sen. Charles Schumer (D-N.Y.) that he would enforce an anti-torture law if Congress were to pass one. "Can our standards have really sunk so low? Enforcing the law is the job of the attorney general. It's a prerequisite, not a virtue."
Enforcing the law is even more important in a Justice Department that has been badly damaged by an attorney general who put partisan loyalty above the rule of law. The nation cannot afford to have that happen again. Yet by refusing to be clear in his answers on whether he considers waterboarding illegal, Mukasey gives no assurance that he would do anything differently than his predecessor, Alberto Gonzales.
Common Cause is urging the full Senate to vote AGAINST Murkasey's confirmation, and the organization is far from alone.
Four retired Judge Advocates General (JAGs), the legal arm of the U.S. military, declared unequivocally in a letter to Sen Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) that "waterboarding is inhumane, it is torture, and it is illegal." Twenty-four retired US intelligence officers have also weighed in, asking that the Senate Judiciary Committee hold the nomination until Mukasey clarifies his remarks. Four retired generals have also written to Leahy, agreeing that water boarding is illegal torture in all circumstances.
Judge Mukasey's disingenuous responses about torture show a contempt for Congress and a disturbing willingness to turn his back on the law when the alternative - acknowledging illegal torture - could have troubling implications for the President who nominated him.
The Senate should do the right thing for the country and for the beleaguered Justice Department and reject Mukasey and continue searching for a suitable nominee.